It's completely mathematical now and people still complain about conspiracy, making Henlopen teams play each other, giving private schools an easy path and that kind of thing. Having a subjective committee would be endless bitching and moaning. It's not a perfect system, but it's fair b/c everyone knows the rules ahead of time. If you want to win a championship, beat everyone in your path. Every year there are going to be a couple of teams that don't belong and a couple who do belong but don't make it. And there will be some seeding that looks a little off. But that's because there is no perfect system. NCAA is the same. They throw all kinds of money and resources at that, keeping track of records for every team and for every team that every team played etc.....and then a bunch of experts sit around and do the seeding and the first thing we hear about it who should have made it but got left out and who got in but should not have. In the end you have to beat the other guys.