I’m not saying good players on bad teams shouldn’t be recognized for post season awards. I would think they would make Honorable Mention All State which is still a great accomplishment! But we all know that 95% of the All State teams will be kids that come from winning programs! Duncan is an exception. He would be a big time contributor on either Smyrna or Mtwn. But going back to your original statement that whichever QB wins the championship each year should be all state is basically saying if a kid has 8 TD passes n 13ints but wins the title, that’s your All State QB? Sorry, I just can’t agree. Again, the best QB, with the best stats, on a solid team should be All State. Also, I’m pretty sure that unless you’re 1st Team All Conference you’re not even eligible to make All State? I could be wrong.
I never said championship winning QB should get All State